TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - International arbiters have rejected a Rwanda appeal for damages over the refugee resettlement deal it had signed with the previous British government, which was scrapped by incoming Prime Minister Keir Starmer immediately after taking office in 2024.
The contentious plan, which seemed at risk of being annulled by British courts anyway, foresaw sending migrants who arrive in the UK illegally seeking asylum to Rwanda, where they would be permitted apply for asylum and residency.
The incoming government called it a "gimmick" and a "shocking waste of taxpayer money," saying Britain had already spent the better part of a billion pounds on a scheme that was unlikely ever to take effect as envisaged.
What was the case about?
Rwanda was appealing for two annual payments, each of 50 billion pounds (roughly €58 billion or $67 billion), originally due in April 2025 and 2026 — saying Starmer's government, which took office in the summer of 2024, still owed it these installments.
The Permanent Court of Arbitration found that written diplomatic exchanges between the two countries after Starmer scrapped the deal in 2024 amounted to confimration that the UK would not be making the payments.
For 2025's payment, the decision was a majority verdict; in 2026's case, it was unanimous. The decision was dated May 15, but formally announced by the Hague-based panel on Monday.
"The UK robustly defended its position, and the tribunal has now ruled in favor of the UK on all grounds," the British government said in response.
Government spokesperson Yolande Makolo said Rwanda "respects the tribunal's award and considers the matter concluded" — albeit noting that the 2025 decision had been open to different interpretations.
What was the agreement?
The deal, struck by Starmer's predecessor Rishi Sunak in 2022 and first floated by Boris Johnson before him, aimed to send migrants who arrived illegally in the UK seeking asylum to the East African country.
It included arrangements for payments to Rwanda's government to help cover the costs.
The deal came amid public dissatisfaction in the UK with irregular migration and pressure on the then-Conservative government from more right-wing political forces, not least Nigel Farage, now the leader of Reform UK.
It also coincided with a sharp increase in legal migration, which came despite — or indeed because of — the UK leaving the European Union, a step that advocates like Farage and former Prime Minsiter Boris Johnson had said would lead to reduced migration.
Why was it contentious?
The deal had already run into domestic legal difficulties prior to Labour, which said it would abolish the plan during campaigning, winning the 2024 election and scrapping it.
In November 2023, the UK's Supreme Court ruled that the policy was unlawful. The court said the agreement left people sent to Rwanda open to human rights breaches and that it could not be implemented in its current form. The bill was amended and put through parliament again, but it passed just weeks before elections the Conservatives seemed sure to lose and so never faced renewed legal scrutiny.
Earlier in 2023, flights carrying migrants to Rwanda had been prevented from taking off on the grounds that the deal might not comply with British law. Ultimately, only four people were sent to the East African country on a voluntary basis, the only way it was permissible, before the accord was scrapped.
"The previous government's policy wasted time and 700 million [pounds] of taxpayer money to send four volunteers to Rwanda," a spokesman for the current government alleged.
Rwanda and Starmer's government had already clashed over Britain reducing aid payments to Rwanda, accusing it of supporting the M23 rebel group in the east of the Democratic Republic of Congo, which Kigali denies.
Read: Ex-UK Health Minister Eyes Bid to Replace Keir Starmer
Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News
Rwandan Genocide Suspect Felicien Kabuga Dies in Custody
15 hari lalu
Rwanda's Felicien Kabuga was once one of the world's most-wanted fugitives. He was accused of encouraging and bankrolling the 1994 genocide.
DR Congo, Rwanda Vow to Uphold Trump-Backed Peace Deal
5 Desember 2025
DR Congo President Felix Tshisekedi and his counterpart from Rwanda, Paul Kagame, signed a deal to end the conflict in eastern Congo.
Which Countries Have Committed Genocide Besides Israel?
20 September 2025
Before Gaza, repeated genocide tragedies have occurred in various parts of the world.
U.N. Says Congo's M23 Rebel Offensive Could Spark Regional War
24 Januari 2025
U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres has warned that Congo's M23 conflict risks spiralling into a broader regional war.
Rwanda and Liberia Commend Indonesia for Its Agricultural Achievements
4 September 2024
President of Rwanda Paul Kagame & Agriculture Minister of Liberia, Alexander Nuetah, laud Indonesia for ramping up agricultural productivity.
Today's Top 3 News: Indonesia is Pursuing 'Quality Investment' from China, Minister Says
25 Agustus 2024
Tempo English compiled the top 3 news on Sunday, August 25, 2024.
2nd Indonesia-Africa Forum: Rwanda Hoping to Sign New Agreement with Indonesia
25 Agustus 2024
Rwandan Ambassador expresses hopes of signing several new agreements with Indonesia on the sidelines of the 2nd Indonesia-Africa Forum (IAF).
Rwanda Highlights IAF's Crucial Role for Indonesia-Africa Ties
24 Agustus 2024
Rwanda highlighted the importance of the 2nd Indonesia-Africa Forum for Indonesia and Rwanda, as well as for other participating African countries.
Indonesia, Rwanda Ink MoUs on Three Sectors; Inaugurate Embassy in Jakarta
6 Juni 2024
Indonesia and Rwanda inked several memorandum of understanding (MoU) today, marking a partnership in three sectors.
:strip_icc():format(jpeg):watermark(kly-media-production/assets/images/watermarks/bola/watermark-color-landscape-new.png,1125,20,0)/kly-media-production/medias/5495647/original/074499000_1770385031-barba.jpeg)
