October 17, 2025 | 09:35 am
TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The Indonesian Constitutional Court has partially upheld a lawsuit related to the Job Creation Law. The court's decision exempts indigenous communities living in the forests from the obligation to obtain business permits for plantation activities.
"As long as it is not intended for commercial purposes," said Constitutional Justice Enny Nurbaningsih while reading the ruling on Thursday, October 16, 2025.
According to her, business permits only apply to activities intended for trade in exchange for profit. Meanwhile, indigenous communities have been planting for generations in the forest for non-commercial purposes.
She elaborated that Article 17, paragraph 2 letter b of Law No. 6 of 2023, which serves as the primary norm of Article 110B in Article 37 number 20 of the Annex to Law No. 6 of 2023, also becomes a secondary norm related to the previous Court's decision.
The previous decision essentially provides legal protection for indigenous communities to carry out plantation activities without a permit from the central government because it is done to meet personal needs.
"The petitioner's arguments related to the norm of Article 110B paragraph (1) in Article 37 number 20 of the Annex to Law No. 6 of 2023, according to the Court, are well-founded," said Enny.
Meanwhile, in lawsuit Number 181/PUU-XXII/2024 filed by Sawit Watch, the Court states that Article 17 paragraph (2) letter b in Article 37 number 5 of the Annex to Law No. 6 of 2023 is contrary to the constitution and does not have conditional legal binding force.
Similarly, according to Constitutional Justice Suhartoyo, this also applies to Article 110B paragraph (1) in Article 37 number 20 of the Annex to Law No. 6 of 2023 insofar as it relates to the provisions of the aforementioned norm.
"As long as it is not interpreted as an exception for indigenous communities living through generations within the forest and not intended for commercial purposes," said Suhartoyo when reading the verdict.
Editor’s Choice: AMAN Reports 110 Indigenous Land Conflicts in Early 2025, Largely Linked to Plantation
Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News
Stop the 'Empty Land' Politics in Papua
1 hari lalu
The government's claim of 'empty land' in Papua reveals a colonial mindset, one that erases indigenous communities existence.
Indonesian Gov't, House Urge Constitutional Court to Reject TNI Law Judicial Review
6 hari lalu
Indonesian parliament and the government have jointly urged the Constitutional Court to reject judicial review petitions challenging TNI Law.
Indonesia's DPR Faces Lawsuit Over Lifelong Pension Benefits
13 hari lalu
Two plaintiffs have sued at the court to remove DPR members from lifelong pensions, calling it unfair for taxpayers to fund 5-year service benefits.
Danantara Affirms Patriot Bonds Participation Is Fully Voluntary
14 hari lalu
Danantara is preparing to purchase Patriot Bonds through a private placement scheme. Participation is voluntary.
Building Supply Shortage Hits Jakarta's Central Business District
15 hari lalu
The office market in Jakarta is facing a supply constraint, especially in the central business district. Why?
Indonesian Maritime Ministry Stops Illegal Reclamation in South Konawe
19 hari lalu
The Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries has stopped the illegal use of sea space for reclamation in the coastal area of Ulu Sawa Village, South Konawe.
Indonesian Govt Dismisses Concerns of Journalist Criminalization in PDP Law
23 hari lalu
Ministry of Communication and Digital Directorate General notes concern on PDP Law.
Indonesia Boosts Economic Diplomacy at Davao ICON and DATE 2025
24 hari lalu
The Indonesian Consulate General (KJRI) in Davao City promotes economic and cultural diplomacy in Indonesia by participating in DICON and DATE 2025.
Constitutional Court Rejects Petitions Challenging TNI Law
29 hari lalu
The Constitutional Court (MK) has rejected a formal review of the Indonesian Military or TNI Law filed by the Civil Society Coalition.
Stop the Seizure of Mentawai Customary Forests
35 hari lalu
A third of Sipora Island in Mentawai is threatened by a timber company takeover. The customary forests of two indigenous communities are at risk.
