TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - Former secretary of the State-Owned Enterprises (SOE) Ministry, Muhammad Said Didu, has strongly criticized the verdict against Thomas Trikasih Lembong or Tom Lembong, former Trade Minister (2015-2016), in the sugar import case.
Said asserted that the ruling is not only legally flawed but also dangerous for Indonesian policymakers.
"There are three interesting things I observed. What was considered a state loss was actually a loss for private parties collaborating with SOEs. Imagine the high-speed train project; will [former president] Jokowi be implicated? Because it causes state losses due to collaboration with private parties," Said Didu said after attending the sentencing hearing at the Central Jakarta District Court on Friday, July 18, 2025.
He questioned the judges' logic in equating private gains from SOE collaborations with state losses. "[Projects of] tolls, airports, and others are considered state losses because of collaboration. GoTo collaborated with Telkom. If GoTo also benefited from Telkom, is it considered a state loss?" he posited.
According to Said Didu, if such legal logic prevails, then all state officials who make decisions involving collaboration with the private sector are potentially subject to criminal charges.
"So get ready, ministers will be in even more trouble. Can you imagine [what can happen to] Directors of the SOE Ministry, for how many thousands of years they will be punished because of that collaboration loss," said the former Secretary of SOE Ministry for the 2005-2010 period.
Furthermore, he highlighted that the case implicating Tom Lembong fell outside the authority of his ministerial position at the time. "For example, the collaboration between SOE and the private sector was not within Tom Lembong's authority. There is no authority for the Trade Minister to say that. That's a corporate action; why blame it on him?"
The third point Said emphasized was the basis of the assignment in the meeting minutes, which he deemed irrelevant for bringing Tom to court.
He reiterated that this verdict could have systemic impacts. "I repeat, three strange things: private gains are considered state losses when collaborating with SOE. This means the entire private sector collaborating with SOE and making a profit is considered a state loss. Secondly, it was not Tom Lembong's authority to regulate collaboration with the private sector, so why blame Tom Lembong? That's the authority of the minister in SOE, not the Trade Minister; it's a corporate action. And third, there are other decision assignments that would not typically lead to a case, but are blamed if you don't execute it," he concluded.
Tom Lembong was found guilty of violating Article 2 paragraph (1) of Law Number 31 of 1999 concerning the Eradication of Corruption, as amended by Law Number 20 of 2001, in conjunction with Article 55 paragraph (1) point 1 of the Criminal Code. T
he Central Jakarta District Court sentenced the former Trade Minister to four years and six months in prison and a fine of Rp750 million, or an additional six-month imprisonment if the fine is not paid.
Editor's Choice: Anies Baswedan: Tom Lembong's Verdict Proves Democracy's Fragility
Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News
Anies Baswedan: Tom Lembong's Verdict Proves Democracy's Fragility
2 jam lalu
Tom Lembong was convicted of corruption in the sugar import case from 2015 to 2016.
Court Rules Rp194.7bn State Loss in Tom Lembong Sugar Import Case
10 jam lalu
Judges ruled that the state's financial losses in the Tom Lembong sugar import case fell short of the public prosecutor's allegations.
Fugitive Riza Chalid Still an Indonesian Citizen, AGO Confirms
11 jam lalu
Still at large, Riza Chalid is a suspect in the Pertamina oil import scandal and is believed to be in Malaysia, according to immigration data.
Tom Lembong on Court's Verdict: "No Mens Rea"
23 jam lalu
The Central Jakarta District Court has sentenced Tom Lembong, who served as Trade Minister from 2015 to 2016, to four years and six months in prison.
BREAKING NEWS: Tom Lembong Sentenced to 4.5 Years in Prison for Sugar Import Corruption
1 hari lalu
The panel of judges at the Jakarta Corruption Court declared Tom Lembong guilty of corruption in the sugar import case between 2015 and 2016.
Google, Telkom Summoned by AGO in Chromebook Corruption Probe
1 hari lalu
Google and Telkom have been summoned to testify in the case of Chromebook laptop procurement at the Ministry of Education and Culture Research and Technology during Nadiem's tenure as minister.
Reasons Why the AGO Has Not Named Nadiem Makarim as a Suspect Yet
2 hari lalu
The Attorney General's Office has not named former minister Nadiem Makarim as a suspect as they still need to further examine the evidence.
Indonesians Losing Rp99tn per Year to Adulterated Rice, Minister Says
2 hari lalu
Indonesians suffer losses amounting to Rp99.35 trillion due to adulterated rice circulating in the markets.
Fugitive Riza Chalid Is Not a Singapore Permanent Resident, Immigration Says
3 hari lalu
According to data from Singapore's Immigration and Checkpoints Authority (ICA), Riza Chalid last entered the country in August 2024.
Immigration Says Pertamina Graft Fugitive Riza Chalid Likely in Malaysia
3 hari lalu
The Directorate General of Immigration has revealed that AGO fugitive Muhammad Riza Chalid is believed to be in Malaysia.
